Two quotes for the same job can only be compared once they price the same work. One may include the steels, the waste removal and the making good. Another may leave them out, or list them as provisional sums to be settled later. The lower total is then not the lower price.
This guide shows how to set quotes side by side before you appoint a builder, from the scope and the exclusions to VAT, fees and the payment terms.
Quote or estimate: what is the difference?
A quote is a fixed price, so you know what the work will cost. An estimate is a rough guess, so you might end up paying more. Get the quote in writing rather than relying on a verbal figure[1].
Once you accept a quote, the trader cannot charge more than the quoted price unless one of three things happens. You ask for extra work that the quote does not include. The trader tells you that extra work is needed and you agree to pay for it. Or the trader made a genuine mistake when writing down or working out the price[1].
An estimate gives far less certainty. If a contract does not fix the price or say how it will be fixed, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 says you must pay a reasonable price, and no more[3]. What is reasonable is then argued over after the work is done.
A fixed price is only fixed for the work it describes. A quote that leaves out half the job, or lists the uncertain parts as provisional sums, is partly an estimate whatever it is called. So check the scope before the totals.
What to have ready before you compare
- The drawings and specification each builder priced. Check that every quote names the same revision. A quote priced from an older drawing may simply price less.
- A list of what you will buy yourself. Kitchens, tiles, sanitaryware and flooring may be supplied by you or by the builder.
- The approvals position. Which approvals the job needs, and who you expect to deal with each.
- A comparison sheet. One row for each line in the checklist below, and one column for each builder.
The comparison checklist
Work through the same lines for every quote. Where a quote says nothing about a line, note it: silence is a gap to ask about, not a saving.
Quote comparison checklist
| Line to check | What to look for | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Price basis | A fixed total price, not a daily rate or an estimate[1] | An estimate or a day rate leaves the final bill open |
| Scope | Every item on the drawings and specification, with quantities where they can be measured | Anything left out can come back later as extra work |
| Breakdown | Separate costs for each material and each part of the work[1] | You can compare like with like and see what a change would cost |
| Exclusions | A written list of what is not included | Each exclusion is a cost you still have to cover |
| Provisional sums | Each sum listed with what it is for, and whether it is defined or undefined[2] | The final figure follows the work actually needed, so it can go up or down |
| Prime cost sums | The allowance for each item you will choose later, such as tiles or door furniture[2] | A dearer choice changes the price, so check how the difference is charged |
| Contingency | Whether the builder has included one, or you are expected to hold your own | Counting it twice, or not at all, distorts the comparison |
| VAT | Whether each total includes VAT[1] | At the standard rate, VAT adds a fifth to a total that excludes it[5] |
| Approvals and fees | Who applies for each approval, and whose fees are in the price | A fee left out of the quote still has to be paid by someone |
| Validity | The date the price expires, and when it can go up[1] | An expired quote may be repriced before you sign |
| Programme | A start date and an expected length for the job | If no time is fixed, the law asks only for a reasonable time[3] |
| Payments | The deposit, what triggers each stage payment, and any retention | Paying in stages lets problems be put right before the final payment[1] |
| Changes | How extra or changed work will be priced and agreed | The price should rise only for extra work you ask for or agree to, or a genuine pricing mistake[1] |
Scroll sideways to see all columns
How to compare quotes, step by step
1. Line the scope up against the drawings
Tick off each item on the drawings and the specification in each quote. Foundations, steels, drainage, windows, electrics, plumbing, plastering, flooring and decoration should each appear as priced work or as an exclusion. Check quantities where they can be measured, such as square metres of flooring or the number of sockets. A single total for the whole job cannot be checked this way. That is why a quote should break down the work and materials, with separate costs for each[1].
Look also at the work around the edges: making good after other trades, removing waste, protecting floors and clearing the site. These are easy to leave out of a total and hard to argue about later.
2. List the exclusions
An exclusion is anything the builder has decided not to price. It may sit in a list at the end of the quote, or in a phrase such as "subject to survey". Copy every exclusion on to your sheet and put a figure, or a question mark, against each one. You still have to pay for it. Two quotes are only comparable once each exclusion is priced, or matched by the same exclusion in the other.
3. Separate the provisional sums and prime cost sums
Some work cannot be priced exactly until the building is opened up or the design is finished. Quotes deal with this through allowances. The RICS measurement rules for building work, known as NRM 2, define them:
Provisional sum. A sum set aside for work that cannot yet be described and measured in the normal way. A defined sum comes with the nature of the work, how it fits into the building, its extent and any limits. An undefined sum is for work that cannot yet be described to that level[2].
Prime cost sum. A sum included in a rate to be spent on materials or goods from suppliers. NRM 2 gives supply-only wall tiles, door furniture and facing bricks as examples[2]. In practice it is an allowance for items you will choose later.
The label matters for time as well as money. For a defined sum, the builder is assumed to have allowed for the work in the programme and the site running costs, called preliminaries. For an undefined sum, the builder is assumed not to have made that allowance[2], so it can add time as well as cost.
A quote for a home may use these terms more loosely, so ask what each allowance covers. Then add up the allowances in each quote and see how much of the total they make up. A low quote with large allowances is less certain than a higher one with few. Ask how a choice above an allowance will be charged.
4. Decide who holds the contingency
A contingency is money kept back for risks the quote does not price, such as poor ground. NRM 2 sets out three ways to deal with a risk: transfer it to the contractor, share it, or keep it as the client. A transferred risk comes at a premium, which the client pays for price certainty whether or not the risk happens[2].
Check whether a quote includes a contingency, what it covers and who decides when it is spent. If none does, hold your own, separate from the contract sum. Do not count the same risk twice: a provisional sum for new drainage and a contingency for the same drainage are the same money.
5. Put every total on the same VAT basis
A quote should say whether the price includes VAT[1]. Check every total, because a quote without VAT and one with VAT can look far apart when they are close. Most goods and services carry the standard rate of 20%[5], and work to an existing building is normally standard-rated[4]. A reduced rate can apply in some cases, such as converting premises to a different residential use or renovating empty residential premises[4]. If a quote uses one, ask which rule it relies on.
A business must register for VAT once its taxable turnover for the last 12 months goes over £90,000, and it can choose to register below that[6]. A small builder may therefore quote without VAT. Confirm that in writing rather than assume it.
6. Check who applies for approvals and who pays the fees
For each quote, note who prepares and submits each approval, and whether its fee is in the price.
Planning permission. In England, the national fee for a householder application to enlarge or alter a single house is £548 from 1 April 2026[9].
Building Regulations. A local authority sets its building control charges by the type of work, the inspections, the number of homes and the floor area. A private building control approver agrees its fee with you[8].
Party wall. The building owner usually pays the costs of the award, including the neighbour's surveyor, if the work is solely for the owner's benefit[10].
- Design and engineering. Drawings and structural calculations may be priced separately from the build.
With E&N Build Group, design, structural engineering, planning applications and Building Control submissions can be arranged through us. Or you can appoint your own designer, and we can build from your drawings and specification.
7. Check the validity period and the start date
A quote should say how long the price is valid for, and when the price can go up[1]. Note each expiry date, and ask for an extension before a quote lapses rather than after.
Then compare the programme: the start date, the length of the job and what the start depends on, such as approvals. If a contract fixes no time, the Consumer Rights Act requires the work to be done within a reasonable time[3]. A date in writing is easier to rely on.
8. Read the payment wording
Payment terms say when money changes hands, and they affect the risk you carry:
Deposit. Citizens Advice advises keeping any deposit as low as possible and not agreeing to more than 25%. If one is needed, check whether the trader has insurance to protect it[1].
Stage payments. Paying in stages means problems can be put right before you make the final payment[1]. A stage tied to finished work, such as the roof being on, is clearer than a date.
Retention. A retention is a percentage of the payment that the customer holds back. Typically, half is released at completion and the other half when a defects liability period ends[7].
How you pay. Pay by debit or credit card if you can, and avoid traders who want cash only or everything upfront. If you pay by card, you might be able to get your money back through the card provider[1].
Payment terms vary between builders and between jobs, so compare what each quote actually says.
9. Read how changes will be priced
The quote, or the contract it leads to, should say how extra or changed work is priced and agreed. Changes may be valued at rates from the quote, or by daywork. NRM 2 defines daywork as valuing work by the time spent, the materials used and the plant employed[2]. Under a quote, the price should rise only if you ask for extra work, agree to pay for extra work the builder says is needed, or the builder made a genuine mistake in the price[1]. Running changes on site is covered in the guide to managing changes after work is agreed.
When the quotes still do not line up
One price is far below the rest. Citizens Advice advises caution: it might mean the trader does not have the right skills or experience, or is not being honest[1]. Check the scope and exclusions first, as a missing line may explain the gap.
- A quote gives only a total. Ask for a breakdown by part of the work and by material. Without one, you cannot check the scope or price a change.
- Most of the price is provisional. Ask whether the design or a survey can be finished first, so more of the work can be priced as fixed.
The price is a day rate. A quote should give a fixed total, not a daily rate[1]. With a day rate the number of days is open, so the total is an estimate.
Before you sign: next steps
You should now have one sheet with a fixed total for each builder, on the same VAT basis. Beside it sit the exclusions, the allowances, any contingency, the fees, the validity date, the programme and the payment stages. The best value is the lowest adjusted total, not the lowest headline figure. Put any open questions to the builders in writing.
Then compare how each builder will run the job. Our page on project scope and working arrangements explains what you receive before work starts. With the quotation comes a written scope stating what is included, what is not, and what is provisional because it cannot be known until the work opens up.
When you are ready, request a quotation. The site visit and the written quotation from E&N Build Group are free, and neither commits you to anything. The enquiry asks for the postcode, the type of work, a short description and whether drawings exist.
