When a house runs out of room, there are four ways out: extend, convert the loft, rework the layout you have, or move. They are not exclusive. The right choice depends on what the space is for, what the house and plot allow, and how much disruption you can live with.
This guide compares the four on space gained, disruption, approvals and how the money works. It gives no building prices, because those depend on the house. It does give the Stamp Duty rates for a move, because they are set by law.
How the four options compare
The table shows the usual position for a house in England. Flats, listed buildings and houses in conservation areas have tighter rules, covered option by option below.
Four ways to get more space
| Option | Space gained | Uses garden? | Disruption at home | Approvals usually needed | Where the money goes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Extend | New floor area at the back or side, on one or two storeys | Yes, part of the garden or side return | Ground floor and garden, most of all when the new structure is joined to the house | Permitted development within limits, or planning permission[4]; Building Regulations for most extensions[5]; the Party Wall Act at or near a boundary[12] | New foundations, walls and roof, joined to the existing house |
| Convert the loft | One or more rooms in the roof space | No | Mostly in the roof until the staircase goes in | Often permitted development on a house[6]; Building Regulations always[7]; the Party Wall Act if beams bear on a shared wall[12] | A stronger floor, a staircase, fire safety, insulation and any dormer |
| Rework the layout | No new floor area; existing space used better, or a garage turned into a room | No | Inside the rooms you use every day | No planning permission for internal walls unless listed[8]; Building Regulations for load-bearing walls[9] and garage conversions[11] | Beams where walls carry load, moved services, making good |
| Move | Whatever the next house offers | Depends on the next house | No building work; a sale, a purchase and a move | None for building; Stamp Duty Land Tax on the purchase[1] | Tax and fees that add no floor area |
Scroll sideways to see all columns
The options, one by one
Extend the house
An extension adds floor area at the back or side, and a two-storey extension adds a room above as well. Under permitted development, a single-storey rear extension can go 3 metres beyond the original rear wall, or 4 metres on a detached house. Prior approval allows more[4]. Extensions and other buildings may cover no more than half the land around the original house[4].
On designated land, such as a conservation area, side extensions and rear extensions of more than one storey need planning permission[4]. Most extensions need Building Regulations approval, from the foundations to the electrics[5]. A new wall at the boundary, or foundations dug near a neighbour's building, can bring in the Party Wall Act[12].
The type of extension matters as much as the decision to extend. Compare the extension types and which suits your house, or read what house extensions involve as a building project.
Convert the loft
A loft conversion turns roof space into rooms and uses no garden. On a house it is often permitted development. The added roof space must be no more than 40 cubic metres on a terraced house, or 50 on other houses. Nothing may extend beyond the roof slope facing the street[6]. The rights do not apply to flats or on designated land[6].
Building Regulations approval is always needed. It checks the new floor, the stability of the roof, escape from fire, the stairs and sound insulation[7]. Cutting into a shared wall to take the bearing of a beam is work the Party Wall Act covers[12]. Whether a loft works comes down to head height, the roof structure and where the stairs can go. Check whether your loft is suitable for conversion before you plan around it.
Rework the layout you have
Sometimes the floor area is enough but badly arranged, such as a small kitchen beside a little-used dining room. Building or removing an internal wall should not need planning permission. A listed building is the exception and needs listed building consent[8].
Removing a load-bearing wall needs Building Regulations approval and a structural engineer's calculations. The work can also affect fire escape routes, ventilation, drainage or electrics[9]. If a loft conversion is planned too, design the two together, because the loft needs safe escape from fire[7].
Turning an integral garage into a room does not usually need planning permission, if the work is internal and does not enlarge the building. Some houses have had permitted development rights removed, so check with the council first, particularly on a new housing development[10]. Building Regulations approval is normally needed[11].
Move house
Moving needs no building work, and it is the only option that also changes where you live. It can meet a need the plot or the planning rules cannot. The cost is the transaction, and none of it adds floor area. This guide states only Stamp Duty Land Tax, because it is set by law. The rates are below.
How do the costs compare?
A fair comparison needs a specific house, because each option has its own cost drivers:
- Extension. The size, the ground for the foundations, how much of the back wall is opened up, the roof and glazing, and any new kitchen or bathroom.
- Loft conversion. Whether a dormer is needed for head height, how much strengthening the floor and roof need, the staircase, fire safety and insulation.
- Reworking the layout. Whether the walls carry load, which means beams and an engineer, and whether the kitchen, drainage or wiring move with them.
- Moving. Stamp Duty Land Tax, plus legal, survey, agent and removal fees, which vary by firm and are not covered here.
The first three options also carry fees outside the build. These can include design and structural engineering, a planning application where one is needed, Building Control charges and party wall surveyors. Work to an existing building is normally standard-rated for VAT[13], and the standard rate is 20%[14].
Stamp Duty if you move
Stamp Duty Land Tax is charged on increasing portions of the price you pay for a home[1]. These standard rates have applied since 1 April 2025, and are the rates listed for the 2026 to 2027 tax year[3].
- Up to £125,000: nothing
- £125,001 to £250,000: 2%
- £250,001 to £925,000: 5%
- £925,001 to £1.5 million: 10%
Above £1.5 million: 12%[1]
On a £500,000 home, that is nothing on the first £125,000, £2,500 on the next £125,000 and £12,500 on the remaining £250,000. The total is £15,000. If you buy before you sell your current home, you pay the higher rates, which add 5 percentage points to each band[2][3]. You can claim the extra back if you sell your previous main home within 3 years[2]. First-time buyer relief applies only to a first home, so it does not help a move[1].
Which option suits which situation?
- You need bedrooms or a home office. Look at the loft first, if the head height and roof allow.
- You need a bigger kitchen or family space. An extension, sometimes combined with reworking the rooms it joins.
- The rooms are there but in the wrong place. Rework the layout. It adds no floor area but can change how the ground floor works.
You want space away from the main rooms. Two further routes are a garden room, a building in the garden for working or hobbies with its own permitted development limits, and a basement conversion, where there is a cellar to convert or the ground allows one.
You want to keep the garden. A loft, a garage conversion or a new layout uses none. A two-storey extension gains more floor area for the same patch of garden, but its permitted development limits are tighter[4].
You live in a flat. Permitted development rights for extensions and lofts apply to houses only, so either needs a planning application[4][6].
- You need more than the plot or the rules allow, or a different area. Moving meets both. Weigh the Stamp Duty against a written quotation for building.
Can you stay at home during the work?
An extension affects the ground floor and garden. A loft conversion is mostly in the roof until the staircase goes in. A reworked layout affects the rooms you use every day. Whether you can stay in the house depends on the job, and we say so at the site visit.
